Finance & Facilities Committee
Saguaro
National Club
National Club
Scottsdale, Arizona · Est. 1968
Q1 2026 Financial Reporting Package
January 1 – March 31, 2026 · Year to Date
At a Glance
YTD Revenue
$5.786M
+$107K vs. budget
NOI Before Depr.
$253K
4.4% operating margin
Capital Income
$1.285M
Initiation · Capital dues · Investment
Reserve Coverage
61%
$4.820M balance · On plan
Prepared with the FAC Framework · financiallyastuteclubs.com
Confidential
Board Financial Briefing
Operations
On Plan
The club generated $5.79M in operating revenue through Q1 — $107K ahead of budget. NOI of $253K before depreciation confirms the operating model is working. Dues-to-revenue at 65.9% is above the 60% benchmark.
Revenue
$5.786M
NOI
$253K
Dues Ratio
65.9%
Financial Health
Strong Position
Reserve fund at $4.82M — 61% coverage, above the FAC 60% benchmark. Working capital of $1.47M. Member accounts are 99.9% current. No assessments required or anticipated.
Reserves
$4.820M
Coverage
61%
Working Capital
$1.47M
Capital Program
Executing
Five active capital projects on schedule. Monthly reserve contributions of $120K are current every period. Locker room renovation advancing to Q2 board review. Reserve fund has capacity to support all planned investments.
Active Projects
$620K
Mo. Contribution
$120K ✓
Capital Income
$1.285M
Financial Performance at a Glance
Q1 2026 · January 1 – March 31, 2026 · Year to Date
The financial story in charts. Equity trajectory, operating trends, KPI scorecards, department performance, and dues analysis.
Visual 01–02 of 14
Visual Summary
Member & Board Level
Pages 1–2
Visual Summary
Charts and KPIs. Start here. The financial story in pictures.
Pages 3–4
KPI Scorecard & P&L
Are we on plan? The board-level operating and capital check-in.
Pages 5–7
Capital & Projects
Reserve health, active projects, and operational context.
Pages 8–10
Detailed Statements
Department detail, balance sheet, and AR. For the finance committee.
Equity Value Over Time
"Is the club's financial health growing, stagnant, or declining?"
Net Worth
7.4%
Actual CAGR
5.5%
Best-in-Class
3.5%
Min. Required
$31.0M
Current Equity
Compounded annual equity growth of 7.4% since 2018 exceeds both the 5.5% best-in-class benchmark and the 3.5% minimum required to outpace asset inflation. Clubs growing equity at less than 3.5% annually are falling behind replacement cost increases.
Operating Results — 12-Month Rolling Trend
Actual vs. Budget vs. Prior Year · Break-Even Zone (−2.8% to +3.3%)
NOI Trend
$45K
YTD NOI
0.3%
% of Revenue
$0
Budget Goal
($193K)
Prior Year
Year-end NOI of $45K (0.3%) sits squarely in the ClubBenchmarking break-even zone of −2.8% to +3.3%. Prior year's ($193K) deficit has been recovered. Consistent performance in this zone confirms dues are properly sized against the operating footprint.
Operating Stewardship — KPI Scorecard
Is the club living within the operating plan?
On Track
Monitor
Action
Metric
Actual
Budget
Benchmark
Non-Profit Operating Ledger
Dues-to-Revenue Ratio
↑
Operating dues as % of total revenue — must exceed the payroll ratio.
Actual
65.9%
Budget
67.2%
Benchmark
≥60%
Initiation Fee Operating Subsidy
↓
Best practice: $0. Initiation fees belong in capital, not daily operations.
Actual
$1.07M
Budget
$1.04M
Benchmark
$0
Payroll & Benefits Ratio
→
Total loaded payroll ÷ operating revenue. Dues ratio must exceed this.
Actual
59.2%
Budget
58.2%
Benchmark
57%+
NOI Variance to Budget
↑
$0 is the goal. Falling within ±3% is the acceptable break-even zone.
Actual
$45K fav.
Budget
$0
Benchmark
±3% zone
NOI as % of Operating Revenue
✓
ClubBenchmarking break-even zone: −2.8% to +3.3%.
Actual
0.3%
Budget
0.0%
Benchmark
−2.8/+3.3%
F&B Subsidy % of Dues
→
Healthy range (12%–21%). A ratio below 12% may signal under-investment in the member experience.
Actual
−18%
Budget
−16%
Benchmark
(12%–21%)
Golf Rounds vs. Budget
↑
Engagement signal — member utilization of the primary amenity.
Actual
6,483
Budget
5,455
Benchmark
+1,028
F&B Covers vs. Budget
↓
Total dining covers as a measure of social engagement vs. plan.
Actual
24,207
Budget
29,310
Benchmark
−5,103
Capital Stewardship — KPI Scorecard
Is the club protecting its future?
On Track
Monitor
Action
Metric
Actual
Budget/Goal
Best-in-Class
Capital Ledger & Balance Sheet Health
Equity Growth (CAGR 2018–Now)
↑
Min. 3.5% annually to outpace inflation and rising asset replacement costs.
Actual
7.4%
Goal
5.9%
Benchmark
5.5%+
Equity-to-Assets Ratio
↑
How much of club assets are owned by members vs. leveraged through debt.
Actual
77.2%
Goal
77.0%
Benchmark
66%+
Capital Reserve % of Assets
↓
Critical measure of the club's ability to fund annual asset replacement.
Actual
11.7%
Goal
14.0%
Benchmark
14%+
Net Available Capital Ratio
✓
Net available capital as % of operating revenue, after the NOI result.
Actual
26.2%
Goal
34.7%
Benchmark
20%+
Net Capital > Depreciation?
✓
Must cover depreciation — a real future cost, not just an accounting entry.
Actual
YES
Goal
YES
Benchmark
Required
Long-Term Debt-to-Equity
↑
Low debt relative to equity. Under 25% is healthy for private clubs.
Actual
3.3%
Goal
3.4%
Benchmark
≤25%
Net PPE to Gross PPE Ratio
↓
Asset age indicator. Below 40% signals aging facilities needing investment.
Actual
31%
Goal
35%
Benchmark
55%+ target
Total Capital Income vs. Budget
↓
Shortfall driven by reduced lot sales; operational capital income on track.
Actual
$4.44M
Budget
$6.03M
Benchmark
−$1.59M
Department Net Performance Highlights
Actual vs. Budget YTD · Net department result after all expenses
Dept Summary
| Department | YTD Actual | YTD Budget | Variance | Trend |
|---|
Golf Operations and Equestrian both beat budget. F&B subsidy of $1.89M (−18% of dues) sits within the healthy (12%–21%) range — lower is not better. Golf Course Maintenance is the club's largest single cost center at $2.88M.
Dues Subsidy Analysis
"What do my club dues pay for?" — allocation of operating expenses
Dues Breakdown
Total Operating Dues:
$10.38M
/ 253 Members =
~$41K / member / yr
Payroll Analysis — Department Breakdown
Actual vs. Budget vs. Prior Year · All departments
Labor Report
$9.87M
Total YTD Payroll
$122K
vs. Budget
$613K
vs. Prior Year
59.2%
Payroll Ratio
Dues Revenue Covers Payroll Check: Operating Dues ($10.38M) exceed Total Payroll & Benefits ($9.87M) by $511K. Dues-to-Revenue Ratio (62.3%) exceeds Payroll Ratio (59.2%). This is the required condition for a financially healthy club operating model. PASS ✓
Payroll Ratio — Monthly Trend
Payroll as % of revenue · Actual vs. budget · Benchmark 57%+
Ratio Trend
59.2%
YTD Ratio
58.2%
Budget Ratio
55.3%
Prior Year
57%+
Benchmark
The payroll ratio has risen vs. prior year (+3.9 pts). This reflects the hiring required to support increased member activity — golf rounds up 20%+ vs. prior year. A rising payroll ratio in tandem with rising member utilization is evidence of delivering the experience, not a cost problem. The dues ratio (62.3%) continues to exceed the payroll ratio (59.2%), confirming the model is properly funded.
Club Financial Visual Dashboard · Q1 2026 Financial Package · 10 Pages · Visuals First — Statements Follow · Financially Astute Clubs · Jeff DeKruif, CCM, CHAE, PGA Assoc. · Nick Gerstner, CCM, CFE · Replace sample figures with actual club data
Hypothetical Illustration · Saguaro National Club · Financially Astute Clubs · financiallyastuteclubs.com
Stewardship KPI Dashboard
Q1 2026 · January 1 – March 31, 2026 · Year to Date
Red · Yellow · Green — Is the club on track across all operating and capital dimensions?
Statement 03 of 14
KPI Dashboard
Board & Finance Committee
$5.786M
Total Operating Revenue
+$107K vs. budget
$253K
NOI Before Depreciation
−$130 vs. budget · 4.4% margin
$1.285M
Capital Fund Income YTD
Initiation fees, capital dues & investment income
61%
Reserve Coverage Ratio
$4.82M balance · FAC benchmark ≥60%
Operating Stewardship
Is the club living within the plan?
These metrics confirm the operating model is sustaining the member experience without borrowing from capital or future years.
Dues-to-Revenue Ratio
↑
Operating dues as % of total revenue — must exceed the payroll ratio.
Actual
65.9%
Budget
67.2%
Benchmark
≥60%
Initiation Fee Operating Subsidy
↓
Best practice: $0. Initiation fees belong in capital, not daily operations.
Actual
$1.07M
Budget
$1.04M
Benchmark
$0
Payroll & Benefits Ratio
→
Total loaded payroll ÷ operating revenue. Dues ratio must exceed this.
Actual
59.2%
Budget
58.2%
Benchmark
57%+
NOI Variance to Budget
↑
$0 is the goal. Falling within ±3% is the acceptable break-even zone.
Actual
$45K fav.
Budget
$0
Benchmark
±3% zone
NOI as % of Operating Revenue
✓
ClubBenchmarking break-even zone: −2.8% to +3.3%.
Actual
0.3%
Budget
0.0%
Benchmark
−2.8/+3.3%
F&B Subsidy % of Dues
→
Healthy range (12%–21%). A ratio below 12% may signal under-investment in the member experience.
Actual
−18%
Budget
−16%
Benchmark
(12%–21%)
Golf Rounds vs. Budget
↑
Engagement signal — member utilization of the primary amenity.
Actual
6,483
Budget
5,455
Benchmark
+1,028
Capital Stewardship
Is the club protecting its future?
These metrics confirm capital obligations are being funded, projects are executing on plan, and the club's long-range asset position is moving in the right direction.
F&B Covers vs. Budget
↓
Total dining covers as a measure of social engagement vs. plan.
Actual
24,207
Budget
29,310
Benchmark
−5,103
Equity Growth (CAGR 2018–Now)
↑
Min. 3.5% annually to outpace inflation and rising asset replacement costs.
Actual
7.4%
Goal
5.9%
Benchmark
5.5%+
Equity-to-Assets Ratio
↑
How much of club assets are owned by members vs. leveraged through debt.
Actual
77.2%
Goal
77.0%
Benchmark
66%+
Capital Reserve % of Assets
↓
Critical measure of the club's ability to fund annual asset replacement.
Actual
11.7%
Goal
14.0%
Benchmark
14%+
Net Available Capital Ratio
✓
Net available capital as % of operating revenue, after the NOI result.
Actual
26.2%
Goal
34.7%
Benchmark
20%+
Net Capital > Depreciation?
✓
Must cover depreciation — a real future cost, not just an accounting entry.
Actual
YES
Goal
YES
Benchmark
Required
Long-Term Debt-to-Equity
↑
Low debt relative to equity. Under 25% is healthy for private clubs.
Actual
3.3%
Goal
3.4%
Benchmark
≤25%
Dashboard Notes
The operating panel confirms the club is running close to plan. Variances that exist are understood, authorized, or attributable to known timing factors — not structural cost growth. The most important operating signals are clean AR and strong working capital.
The capital panel shows the club at the FAC 60%+ reserve coverage benchmark. The Net-to-Gross PP&E ratio of 44% is below the 50% benchmark, indicating aging assets. The board should be aware that as this ratio declines over time, the argument for accelerating reserve contributions strengthens — the club is managing assets that are depreciating faster than they are being rebuilt.
Hypothetical Illustration · Saguaro National Club · Financially Astute Clubs · financiallyastuteclubs.com
$5.786M
YTD Operating Revenue
+$107K vs. budget · 8 weeks
$253K
NOI Before Depreciation
4.4% margin · $130 below budget
Positive territory
65.9%
Dues-to-Revenue Ratio
Above 60% benchmark
On track
59.2%
Payroll-to-Revenue Ratio
vs. 58.2% budget · monitor
Slight pressure
Statement of Activities — Two-Fund Format
Q1 2026 · January 1 – March 31, 2026 · Year to Date
Operating revenues and expenses above the NOI line. Capital revenues below it — separated by institutional discipline, not accounting convention.
Statement 04 of 14
Financial Statement
Finance Committee
| Category | Mar Budget | Mar Actual | Mar Var | YTD Budget | YTD Actual | YTD Var | % Var |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Operating Revenue — Covenant Foundation | |||||||
| Membership Dues | 390,525 | 390,525 | — | 1,171,575 | 1,169,525 | (2,050) | -0.2% |
| Service Assessment | 100,119 | 105,067 | 4,948 | 300,355 | 300,355 | — | 0.0% |
| Total Dues Revenue | 490,644 | 495,592 | 4,948 | 1,471,930 | 1,469,880 | (2,050) | -0.1% |
| Golf Operations | |||||||
| Golf — Guest Fees | 85,000 | 56,832 | (28,168) | 168,750 | 123,401 | (45,349) | -26.9% |
| Member rounds up 30% vs. prior year — member tee times are filling slots previously occupied by guests. Engagement signal, not a revenue management failure. | |||||||
| Golf — Cart Fees | 55,150 | 75,817 | 20,667 | 165,450 | 203,497 | 38,047 | +23.0% |
| Golf — Merchandise | 72,000 | 77,786 | 5,786 | 186,300 | 179,954 | (6,346) | -3.4% |
| Golf — Tournaments & Other Income | 104,965 | 133,711 | 28,746 | 233,517 | 266,787 | 33,270 | +14.2% |
| Total Golf Operations | 317,115 | 344,146 | 27,031 | 754,017 | 773,639 | 19,622 | +2.6% |
| Food & Beverage | |||||||
| F&B — Ala Carte Food | 135,250 | 152,760 | 17,510 | 379,710 | 416,736 | 37,026 | +9.7% |
| F&B — Ala Carte Beverage | 90,679 | 87,657 | (3,022) | 245,698 | 239,318 | (6,380) | -2.6% |
| F&B — Banquet & Private Events | 15,293 | 10,484 | (4,809) | 45,355 | 76,439 | 31,084 | +68.5% |
| Total Food & Beverage | 241,222 | 250,901 | 9,679 | 670,763 | 732,493 | 61,730 | +9.2% |
| Amenities & Other | |||||||
| Fitness Center | 44,633 | 43,210 | (1,423) | 133,900 | 115,525 | (18,375) | -13.7% |
| Racquet Operations | 24,750 | 21,705 | (3,045) | 74,250 | 71,027 | (3,223) | -4.3% |
| Aquatics & Pool | 12,600 | 14,200 | 1,600 | 37,800 | 41,850 | 4,050 | +10.7% |
| Locker & Member Services | 5,125 | 5,245 | 120 | 15,375 | 14,985 | (390) | -2.5% |
| Other Income | 19,435 | 22,402 | 2,967 | 49,035 | 52,308 | 3,273 | +6.7% |
| Total Amenity & Other Revenue | 106,543 | 106,762 | 219 | 310,360 | 295,695 | (14,665) | -4.7% |
| Total Operating Revenue | 1,155,524 | 1,197,401 | 41,877 | 3,207,070 | 3,271,707 | 64,637 | +2.0% |
| Operating Expenses | |||||||
| Cost of Sales — Golf Merchandise | 53,400 | 51,917 | 1,483 | 138,120 | 128,505 | 9,615 | +7.0% |
| Cost of Sales — Food | 70,301 | 90,217 | (19,916) | 199,728 | 219,479 | (19,751) | -9.9% |
| March food cost 56% vs. 48% budget — Easter product ordering timing; expected to normalize Q2 | |||||||
| Cost of Sales — Beverage & Retail | 42,062 | 38,794 | 3,268 | 115,814 | 118,838 | (3,024) | -2.6% |
| Beverage cost 34% vs. 39% budget YTD — well-controlled, offsetting food timing variance | |||||||
| Cost of Sales — Other | 5,036 | 2,269 | 2,767 | 14,142 | 10,364 | 3,778 | +26.7% |
| Total Cost of Sales | 170,799 | 183,197 | (12,398) | 467,804 | 477,186 | (9,382) | -2.0% |
| Payroll — All Departments | 1,032,620 | 1,043,640 | (11,020) | 3,030,191 | 3,050,304 | (20,113) | -0.7% |
| Benefits & Payroll-Related | 158,075 | 165,047 | (6,972) | 489,934 | 501,717 | (11,783) | -2.4% |
| Total Payroll & Related | 1,190,695 | 1,208,687 | (17,992) | 3,520,125 | 3,552,021 | (31,896) | -0.9% |
| Golf Operations — Other Expenses | 110,421 | 141,303 | (30,882) | 247,607 | 289,833 | (42,226) | -17.1% |
| Includes ~$30K tournament expenses that are largely offset by corresponding tournament revenue above | |||||||
| F&B — Other Expenses | 35,427 | 42,630 | (7,203) | 100,672 | 120,350 | (19,678) | -19.6% |
| Course & Grounds Maintenance | 97,943 | 100,075 | (2,132) | 258,481 | 265,949 | (7,468) | -2.9% |
| Facilities & Maintenance | 98,766 | 92,161 | 6,605 | 278,677 | 266,067 | 12,610 | +4.5% |
| General & Administrative | 86,862 | 96,354 | (9,492) | 254,173 | 275,768 | (21,595) | -8.5% |
| Amenities — Other Expenses | 73,178 | 79,539 | (6,361) | 183,228 | 196,294 | (13,066) | -7.1% |
| Total Other Operating Expenses | 502,597 | 552,062 | (49,465) | 1,322,838 | 1,414,261 | (91,423) | -6.9% |
| Fixed Expenses — Insurance, Taxes & Other | 28,408 | 28,513 | (105) | 85,225 | 85,595 | (370) | -0.4% |
| Net Operating Income Before Depreciation | 73,941 | 113,857 | (39,916) | 253,591 | 253,460 | (130) | -0.1% |
| Depreciation | (350,000) | (345,274) | 4,726 | (1,050,000) | (1,029,122) | 20,878 | +2.0% |
| Net Operating Income (Loss) After Depreciation | (276,059) | (231,417) | 44,642 | (796,409) | (775,662) | 20,747 | +2.6% |
Capital Fund & Non-Operating — Below This Line
Initiation fees, capital dues, and investment income are capital governance revenues — not operating income. They belong below the operating result so the board evaluates the operating model and the capital funding model independently, every period.
| Capital Fund Activity | Mar Budget | Mar Actual | Mar Var | YTD Budget | YTD Actual | YTD Var | % Var |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Initiation Fees — Capital Revenue | |||||||
| Initiation Fees — New Members | 180,000 | 240,000 | 60,000 | 540,000 | 480,000 | (60,000) | -11.1% |
| 7 new memberships Q1. YTD timing variance — annual forecast of 28 memberships remains achievable at current pace. | |||||||
| Capital Dues — Recurring Capital Funding | |||||||
| Capital Dues — Monthly Assessment | 160,000 | 160,000 | — | 480,000 | 480,000 | — | On Plan |
| The most reliable capital funding source — contractual, recurring, and not dependent on housing market or membership demand cycles. | |||||||
| Investment Income & Other Capital Sources | |||||||
| Investment Income — Reserve Fund | 14,583 | 16,124 | 1,541 | 43,750 | 46,200 | 2,450 | +5.6% |
| Gain on Asset Disposals | — | — | — | — | 6,700 | 6,700 | — |
| Capital Fund Expenses | |||||||
| Interest Expense — Long-Term Debt | (4,225) | (3,895) | 330 | (12,918) | (12,888) | 30 | -0.2% |
| Total Capital Fund Activity (Net) | 350,358 | 412,229 | 61,871 | 1,050,832 | 1,000,012 | (50,820) | -4.8% |
| Net Income (Loss) — Combined | 74,299 | 526,086 | 451,787 | 254,423 | 253,350 | (1,073) | -0.4% |
CFO Commentary — Q1 2026
The operating model is essentially on plan. NOI before depreciation of $253,460 is $130 unfavorable to the $253,591 budget — a variance so small it reflects a business operating precisely as designed. The $107K favorable revenue variance is offset by $32K in payroll and $73K in other operating expenses, both understood and largely activity-driven.
Golf revenue requires context: member rounds are up 30% over prior year, reflecting exceptional member engagement. The unfavorable guest fee variance reflects members filling tee times that previously went to guests. This is a quality-of-experience outcome.
Capital dues of $480,000 are on plan — the most structurally important capital revenue source. Initiation fees of $480,000 are slightly behind YTD budget but remain on annual forecast pace. Monthly reserve contributions have been made as planned.
The two-fund format above separates operating stewardship from capital stewardship deliberately. The board evaluates each section independently: the operating section answers whether the club is living within its means; the capital section answers whether it is funding its obligations to future members.
Q1 2026 — Operating Narrative
Revenue is $107K ahead of budget through Q1, driven by cart fee recovery (+$38K), tournament activity (+$33K), and F&B performance (+$22K). Guest fee softness of −$45K is attributable to member tee time priority, total rounds are up 8.7%, and member engagement is at a multi-year high. The dues-to-revenue ratio of 65.9% comfortably clears the 60% benchmark. NOI of $253K is slightly below the $253.1K budget, a rounding difference, and is fully consistent with institutional plan.
Capital Fund Summary
Capital income of $1.285M YTD is on pace with the annual plan. Initiation fee revenue of $480K reflects seven new memberships in Q1, consistent with the 28-member annual forecast. Reserve contributions are current. No capital line is over budget. The reserve fund balance of $4.820M provides 61% Reserve Coverage Ratio against a total replacement cost base of $7.9M.